Rate your review!

**Dreamly** · by **Dreamly** on Wed Apr 08, 2009 3:34 am

First topic message reminder :

Now that you have your review and read through it we would really appreciate if you helped us improve the reviews by giving us some feedback and suggestions. All your have to do is complete the template below and then post it in this topic. Although is good to hear good comments we really do prefer good, honest feedback because that is what will help us improve this service. It is not required that you do this but we would really appreciate it if you did.

Code:: [b]Username of Reviewer:[/b] [b]How long did you wait for your review?:[/b] [b]Did you have any problems with the timing?:[/b] [b]How did you find your review and did it help you?:[/b] [b]Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?:[/b] [b]Is there any improvements you could suggest?:[/b] [b]Will you be requesting again?:[/b] [b]Mark out of 10:[/b] [b]Link to Review[/b]

Again, it is not required that you do this but it is really appreciated and it helps us improve the overall quality of the service.

**Mario94** · by **Mario94** on Wed Jul 01, 2009 1:56 am

Username of Reviewer: Kiid CuDIi
How long did you wait for your review?: A couple of hours
Did you have any problems with the timing?: None at all
How did you find your review and did it help you?: It showed us what we need to do and yes,
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Absolutely.
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: Maybe leave a bit of personal preference out of the review. And be sure to edit so that your spelling and grammar are correct.
Will you be requesting again?: Definitely.
Mark out of 10: 9.5
Link to Review http://www.forumansion.com/completed-reviews-f57/blue-stadium-review-request-t2156.htm#34084

**Freshko** · by **Freshko** on Wed Jul 01, 2009 1:57 am

Thank you for the feed backs Mario94

**Dreamly** · by **Dreamly** on Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:54 pm

Username of Reviewer: KiiD
How long did you wait for your review?: Less then a day
Did you have any problems with the timing?: Not at all
How did you find your review and did it help you?: Kinda helped me.
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Most of them
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: The thing in member activity... I don't see why you cut all marks of it for just that, be totally honest and give many suggestions! that's what I like!
Will you be requesting again?: Yes..
Mark out of 10: 8
Link to Review http://www.forumansion.com/awaiting-cash-f104/dragon-den-review-t2253.htm#35731

Thanks a ton for the review!

**Freshko** · by **Freshko** on Thu Jul 02, 2009 3:57 pm

Thanks for the rate
Next time i will do my best !

**Dreamly** · by **Dreamly** on Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:06 pm

No Problem! Your review was awesome!

**MrMega** · by **MrMega** on Thu Jul 02, 2009 4:48 pm

Username of Reviewer: Kiid Cudii
How long did you wait for your review?: about 3 hours
Did you have any problems with the timing?: Not at all
How did you find your review and did it help you?: Yes and I found it nice but a few minor misunderstandings is all
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: For the most part, yes
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: Member Activity means if they post a lot and if the like the forum, not if members were online at the time you were there xD Also, about the icons, it means like Announcement, Sticky, new Post, No New Post, locked, not that it had none xD
Will you be requesting again?: Definetely
Mark out of 10: 8
Link to Review http://www.forumansion.com/completed-reviews-f57/dragon-den-review-t2253.htm

My opinion ^^

**Freshko** · by **Freshko** on Thu Jul 02, 2009 7:52 pm

Thank you
I took 1 hour exact Suspect

**RedRose** · by **RedRose** on Wed Jul 08, 2009 6:25 pm

Username of Reviewer: MiniRadi
How long did you wait for your review?:About 9 hours
Did you have any problems with the timing?: Not at all
How did you find your review and did it help you?: I found the review very complimentary, and yes it did help me
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Yes I do
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: One improvement I would suggest is that the reviewer registers on the forum in order to see everything. Also Mini tended to repeat himself a few times Razz

But that's not a biggie
Will you be requesting again?:Absolutely
Mark out of 10: 9
Link to Review http://www.forumansion.com/completed-reviews-f57/chit-chat-chatterbox-review-t2470.htm

by Guest on Fri Jul 10, 2009 4:30 am

ok Cool thanks i won't repeat myself next time.

**Hallucinogen** · by **Hallucinogen** on Sun Jul 19, 2009 3:29 am

Username of Reviewer: Chris
How long did you wait for your review?: 2 days.
Did you have any problems with the timing?: Not at all.
How did you find your review and did it help you?: Some.
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Quite.
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: Not quite.
Will you be requesting again?: Sure.
Mark out of 10: 8
Link to Review Click
Another Comment: Chris, that Nav it's basically an iPod design ;P so the Login/off button is suppose to be like that anyhow, thanks.

**Mayday!** · by **Mayday!** on Tue Jul 28, 2009 12:20 am

Username of Reviewer: NaXuh
How long did you wait for your review?: About less than a day, but it was worth it.
Did you have any problems with the timing?: No, not really. I had other things to take care of whilst waiting. Cool

How did you find your review and did it help you?: I thought it was a pretty nice review. I was looking for criticism other than comments, and I got what I want.
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Definitely.
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: No, nice review.
Will you be requesting again?: Nod

Mark out of 10: 9/10
Link to Review http://www.forumansion.com/forum-reviews-f42/forumania-review-t3012.htm#44652

**iKinky** · by **iKinky** on Tue Jul 28, 2009 9:18 pm

Username of Reviewer: NaXuh
How long did you wait for your review?: like...6hours (great speed)
Did you have any problems with the timing?: No!
How did you find your review and did it help you?: yes, it will help us alot Happy

Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Yes, i do, alot, altouigh we've tried to fix them with no luck Sad

Is there any improvements you could suggest?: um...No not really.
Will you be requesting again?: Yes!!!!!
Mark out of 10: 9
Link to Review http://www.forumansion.com/forum-reviews-f42/universal-discourse-t3051.htm#45007

by Guest on Sun Aug 16, 2009 7:58 am

Username of Reviewer: Comkid
How long did you wait for your review?: about 15 minutes
Did you have any problems with the timing?: No way!
How did you find your review and did it help you?: i loved it, yes it did help me
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Yes
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: Yes, try and not repeat your self Happy

Will you be requesting again?: Yes
Mark out of 10:9
Link to Review Here

**ack!** · by **ack!** on Wed Aug 19, 2009 5:19 pm

Username of Reviewer:
Chris

How long did you wait for your review?:
Three days

Did you have any problems with the timing?:
Nah. Whatever. You guys have lives too.

How did you find your review and did it help you?:
It's helped me kick my butt into gear over a couple of things I knew were a problem, but tried to ignore. It's good to see an outside review on it.

Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?:
I agree with about 50% of it. Some of the concerns were really outlandish and silly (to me). Granted a lot of it is butthurt, but I think some of us are willing to understand if it takes longer for a review to be done because the reviewer needs to sign-up, it's all right.

The comments about lacking a banner and the navbar make no sense to me. The header image IS the banner, and the navbar is not as important as the actual menu for the site. Also, it sounds like most of the forum was judged based on the first page. If he had continued he would have seen the topic icons, custom emoticons, and custom images.

The one thing I do agree with, that has kicked me to ask my members, is the current style. S*T has a long history of being girly (mainly because for a few years there, it was ALL girls). In this recent style, I tried to make it somewhere in the middle. I still fell short. It will be changed shortly when the next template is complete.

I wish I had known to set up a reviewer account first, because a lot of stuff was missed. The fact that we have a darker, more male friendly template available to our users would have helped my score quite a bit... But I don't expect guests to know that we have other templates, and it's something I'm working on fixing.

Is there any improvements you could suggest?:
Wait for your account to be accepted first. You missed a lot of things that you had marked me down for.

Will you be requesting again?:
Probably.

Mark out of 10:
6.5/10

Link to Review
http://www.forumansion.com/awaiting-cash-f104/a-review-for-surrealtwilight-t3424.htm

**Lord of Games** · by **Lord of Games** on Tue Aug 25, 2009 3:12 am

Username of Reviewer: WhatIf

How long did you wait for your review?: 1 day

Did you have any problems with the timing?: No

How did you find your review and did it help you?: I found it was too 'fast' and didn't suggest many ways on how to improve what the reviewer pointed out wasn't good.

Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Partly. The banner image was created on Forumotion, so no it is not copyright protected. I also don't think everything 'jumps out at you'. Where I do agree, is that the banner doesn't match the nav bar, and I am in the midst of changing that.

Is there any improvements you could suggest?:Although it was supposed to be a quick review, I felt it was a little too quick, and as I said above, just pointed out mostly negative and didn't offer many ways to improve.

Will you be requesting again?: More than likely, however it will be full.

Mark out of 10: 5
Link to Review http://www.forumansion.com/forum-reviews-f42/quick-review-request-t3575.htm

**Whatif** · by **Whatif** on Tue Aug 25, 2009 3:43 am

I'm sorry you feel that way.
If i pointed out great thing, it wouldn't be a very constructive review now would it?

I just gave you links to the GFX sections here and at forumotion, as well as advice to promote here.

Those are really your only flaw Wink

I'll make it more detailed next time

**Fayko** · by **Fayko** on Thu Aug 27, 2009 11:42 pm

Username of Reviewer: WhatIF
How long did you wait for your review?:a few hours
Did you have any problems with the timing?: Nope
How did you find your review and did it help you?: was helpful and gave me some pointers
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: mostly.
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: Not really
Will you be requesting again?: Definitely.
Mark out of 10: 8
Link to Review http://www.forumansion.com/forum-reviews-f42/design-layout-review-tagged-whatif-t3624.htm

**Nuke** · by **Nuke** on Mon Oct 26, 2009 12:27 pm

Username of Reviewer: MrJohn
How long did you wait for your review?: Too long.
Did you have any problems with the timing?: Yes, but I understand your problems and think that they are legit. Hope you do better timing if I request again.
How did you find your review and did it help you?: The advice only helped me on one thing since most of it was telling me to advertise XD
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Yeah, although he didn't notice that Mutant has more posts than the forum.
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: Correction, it should say "are" Not many, no.
Will you be requesting again?: Yes, but another forum I'm active at is doing free reviews XD
Mark out of 10: 9.5.
Link to Review

**CodyCFS** · by **CodyCFS** on Mon Oct 26, 2009 10:00 pm

Username of Reviewer: Crystal
How long did you wait for your review?: Well, i waited about 3 weeks. But it took crystal 2 days.
Did you have any problems with the timing?: No =)
How did you find your review and did it help you?: I liked how she told me the truth.
Do you agree with the things that were said in your review?: Every single thing.
Is there any improvements you could suggest?: Not anything. Great Job. I like your style.
Will you be requesting again?: Most Definatly
Mark out of 10: 10.5
http://www.forumansion.com/awaiting-cash-f104/cfs-full-t4160.htm